Subtlety not being part of
Christina Aguilera's vocabulary, she trades the retro-swing of
Back to Basics for the future-pop of
Bionic, receiving assists from a roster that reads like a who's who of progressive pop:
M.I.A.,
Le Tigre,
Peaches, and
John Hill and
Switch, known for their work with
Santogold. But like the half-cyborg/half-diva illustration of the cover, this revamp is only partial.
Aguilera hedges her bets by adding a ballad from old friend
Linda Perry, gets
Tricky Stewart to produce a trio of cuts, and drafts
Polow da Don and
Focus to produce some heavy and slow R&B, letting enough air into the machines to reassure hesitant fans that she hasn't abandoned her roots. All this hesitancy means that for as many risks as it takes,
Bionic doesn't feel daring.
–
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi