The Smithsonian's four-disc tribute to the swing/big band era, compiled by the late, great
Martin Williams, offers as comprehensive a look at the genre as possible from a general perspective.
Williams featured great and lightweight bands, highly popular vocalists like
Bing Crosby and
Frank Sinatra, dubious ones with large followings like
Bob Eberly and
Doris Day and underrated ones such as
Al Hibbler and
Helen Humes.
Duke Ellington,
Count Basie,
Woody Herman and
Benny Goodman are well-represented, but so are
Harry James,
Glenn Miller and
Bob Crosby. The sound quality is first-rate and the liner notes are informative, and the material is nicely divided between familiar cuts and obscure tracks. The Smithsonian's sets are sometimes attacked for emphasizing one style over another or not representing each era of a genre; that cannot be leveled at this anthology.
–
Ron Wynn, Rovi