Even before her all-too-tragic passing in 1978,
Sandy Denny was touted as England's premiere female folk vocalist. However, gratuitous comparisons with contemporaries
Jacqui McShee and
Joni Mitchell seem to have been more of an albatross or doubled-edged sword than confirmation of
Denny's wholly individualistic style. Depending on which side of the aisle the respective listener and potential consumer sits -- as curious enthusiast or dyed-in-the-wool
Denny convert -- this 88-track compilation can be interpreted as (a) either the final word on the artist or (b) another in a series of multi-disc collections that falls short of offering all the essentials within her voluminous songbook. Parties falling in the latter camp can undoubtedly point to excluded favorites -- from
Denny's participation as half of Sandy & Johnny, as a member of
Fairport Convention,
the Strawbs,
Fotheringay or on her own -- as evidence that only a 'complete' anthology could capture all that
Denny has to offer. From that perspective, they would be just as correct as someone whose piqued interests are thoroughly satiated by the nearly six hours of audio included on
Boxful of Treasures (2004). The contents are presented in a primarily chronological fashion, commencing with the powerful cover of "3.10 to Yuma" -- from
Denny's professional debut backed by Roger Evans (guitar) and
David Moses (bass) -- which had been a hit for pop singer
Frankie Lane. Immediately established is
Denny's commanding prowess and sensitivity, particularly pervasive on the originals "They Don't Seem to Know You" and appropriately enough "Boxful of Treasure" -- a song which would resurface in due time under the name "Fotheringay." These are equalled by
Denny's arrangements of "She Moves Through the Fair" and the haunting "Geordie" -- all sourced from a smattering of lo-fi homemade recordings in 1967. Other formative zeniths from her collaborations with Evans and
Moses are the empathetic overhaul of
Jackson C. Frank's "You Never Wanted Me" and joined by
Alex Campbell (vocals) on the gospel-infused "This Train." By mid-'68,
Denny had become a member of
the Strawbs and her contributions to
Dave Cousins' "Sail Away to Sea," "Tell Me What You See in Me" and most notably, the first reading of "Who Knows Where the Time Goes" are spotlighted. When contrasted to her incipient demos, both the outstanding and never-before-available "Autopsy" as well as "Now and Then" -- which initially turned up on the triple-CD
Who Knows Where the Time Goes (1985) -- are decidedly more polished, but no less emotionally gripping. As
Denny's involvement with
Fairport Convention has been widely documented, there are but a few rarities from her '68/'69 stint with the aggregate. One of which is the oft-circulated, yet previously unreleased rendition of "Sir Patrick Spens" lifted off a Top Gear BBC Radio session for
John Peel on September 23, 1969. The tunes from the
Fairport studio platters
What We Did on Our Holidays (1969),
Unhalfbricking (1969) and
Liege & Lief (1969) are adeptly chosen, if not somewhat obligatory. The same holds true for the eponymous
Fotheringay (1970) long-player, with the sizable exception of a newly unearthed take of "Silver Threads & Golden Needles" that is beautiful in its sparseness. Not to mention "Late November," a cut that was on the Island Records various-artists compilation
El Pea (1971). Two of the volumes are dedicated to
Denny's '70s solo career and luckily there are plenty of nuggets from the era unveiled within and scattered among the offerings from the LPs
North Star Grassman and the Ravens (1971),
Sandy (1972),
Like an Old Fashioned Waltz (1973) and the posthumous
BBC Sessions (1997). They include an alternate version of "Next Time Around" (sans string arrangement) circa
North Star Grassman. Plus, unaccompanied renderings of "Sweet Rosemary" and "The Lady" from
Sandy, in addition to "No End" and "At the End of the Day" (sans strings) from
Like an Old Fashioned Waltz. It bears repeating these are all exclusive contents on
Boxful of Treasures. By the middle part of the 1970s, the results of
Denny's indulgences began to permeate her craft. She returned to the re-formation of
Fairport Convention for
Rising for the Moon (1974) before splitting again, emerging on what would become her final album
Rendezvous (1977). This late period is punctuated with a bevy of rarities and outtakes. A live
Fairport interpretation of "John the Gun" and "She Moves Through the Fair" hail from the February '74 shows at the Troubadour in Los Angeles. While an austere piano demo of the
Rising for the Moon piece "One More Chance" will be worth the price of admission alone for some. those purchasing first-edition copies of the assemblage will undoubtedly be ecstatic with the fifth or 'bonus' CD, fittingly dubbed "
A Collection of Rarities and Demos." Only three of the 17 selections have ever ascended over the years, leaving a host of titles that may be familiar to
Denny fans, but certainly not as they appear on this package. Regardless of the consumer's prior knowledge or interest in
Sandy Denny, it is here that she is at her most arrestingly poignant. "Take Me Away," "No More Sad Refrains," "Take Away the Load" and "Full Moon" are nothing short of organic aural jewels. As fellow
Fairport Convention member
Richard Thompson (guitar/vocal) points out in his introductory essay, "Somewhere the taste gurus have ... failed to tell us, after 20 years of hindsight opportunity, that
Sandy Denny was the greatest British female artist of her generation." Hopefully packages such as this will go a long way in rectifying that and give
Denny the lauds she rightly deserves. The 56-page liner book is replete with photos, song-by-song annotations as well as comments and memories by associates ranging from
John Renbourn,
Danny Thompson,
Ashley Hutchings,
Linda Thompson,
Jerry Donahue,
Simon Nichol,
Ian Matthews,
Dave Mattacks,
John "Rabbit" Bundrick and
Dave Pegg to producer
Joe Boyd and rock & roll family tree designer
Pete Frame -- among others.
–
Lindsay Planer, Rovi